How to Respond to Best Offers on eBay Without Giving Away Your Margin
A Best Offer is a negotiation with a clock on it. When a buyer makes one, eBay emails you, and you have 24 hours to accept, counter or decline before it expires on its own.S1 The way to answer well, and fast, is to decide your lowest acceptable price before the offer arrives, then let that number make most of the decisions.
Your three choices, and the clock on each
- Accept. The listing ends and the buyer pays. In most cases eBay requires buyers who use Best Offer to pay immediately.S1
- Counter. Your counteroffer has to be lower than your Buy It Now price and higher than the buyer's offer. Each counteroffer expires after 96 hours, and if you counter several buyers, whoever accepts first wins.S1
- Decline, or let it expire. An offer you don't answer expires after 24 hours or when the listing ends, whichever comes first.S1
A decline isn't always the end of the conversation: in most categories a buyer can make up to three offers per item.S1
Work out your floor before the first offer
Your margin floor is the lowest profit you'll accept, as a share of what the buyer pays you; your target margin is what you aim for.S4 The floor is the lowest offer you take. The target is roughly where you'd be happy to accept without a second thought.
Here is the worked example from Tyasi's margin floor answer: one US sale in a most-categories listing with no Store, free buyer shipping, an illustrative 8% sales tax, a $20 item cost, a $6 label and $1 of packaging. Ads, insertion fees, returns and overhead are left out.S4 Under those assumptions, the lowest price that keeps a 25% margin is $45.43, and a $50 price clears a 30% target.S4
| Price the buyer pays | eBay fee | Profit | Margin |
|---|---|---|---|
| $45.00 | $7.01 | $10.99 | 24.42% |
| $45.43 | $7.07 | $11.36 | 25.01% |
| $48.00 | $7.45 | $13.55 | 28.23% |
| $50.00 | $7.74 | $15.26 | 30.52% |
Source: Tyasi, "How to set a margin floor for eBay listings".S4
So with the item listed at $50, a $45 offer leaves 24.42%, under the floor: counter rather than accept. A $48 counter would leave 28.23%, above your floor and below your $50 Buy It Now price, which is where eBay requires a counter to sit.S1S4 To build the same table for your own items, follow how to calculate your profit on an eBay saleS5 or use the free fee and profit calculator.S9
Check for an ad fee before you accept
If the listing is promoted, look before you accept. When any buyer clicked one of your Promoted Listings general ads within the last 30 days, and the item was promoted both at that click and at the sale, accepting a Best Offer charges the ad fee on the final total sale amount, including shipping and taxes.S1 That fee comes out of your profit dollar for dollar: on a $50.00 sale with free shipping and no sales tax, a 5% ad rate is $2.50.S6 On a promoted listing, work out the floor with the ad fee included, using the Promoted Listings fee answer.
Let eBay answer the easy offers
In the listing's pricing settings you can set a minimum offer amount and an auto-accept amount.S1 Offers at or above your upper limit are accepted automatically; offers below your lower limit are declined automatically; anything in between comes to you to decide.S1 Buyers can't see your limits, and the upper limit must be below your Buy It Now price.S1
In the example, the lower limit would be your floor, $45.43.S4 The upper limit is your call, as long as it sits below the $50 price: $48.00, for instance, would accept anything that leaves at least 28.23% without asking you.S1S4
Automatic responses don't apply when the item is in a sale event from Discounts Manager, when the buyer has added terms you need to review, or in categories where the option doesn't appear when you list.S1
Check the offer against real sales
Listed prices say what sellers hope for. Seller Hub's Product research reaches back three years and shows the actual accepted Best Offer amounts on items that sold.S8 Look up a few matching items before you set your limits, so your floor and target reflect what buyers actually paid. The sold listings answer walks through the search.
Answering offers in Tyasi
Tyasi gathers every Best Offer into one list where you can accept, decline or counter each one.S2 Its Inventory shows cost, price, profit and margin for every listing, and Groups let you set a margin floor, minimum price and target margin for a set of listings.S2 Groups come with the Operator and Business plans.S3S4 Strategies that reprice a listing never go below that floor.S2
Tyasi does not respond to offers on its own: as its eBay seller app page puts it, every accept, counter and decline is yours to make.S7
Question for TyasiDoes the Best Offers list show a listing's cost or margin floor beside each offer? The features page says the list lets you accept, decline or counter, and that Inventory shows cost and margin, but not whether they appear on the same screen. This section is written to be true either way; answer it and we'll add a line.
Tyasi is for US eBay sellers. Plans start at $29 a month plus tax, and any plan can be tried free for 14 days; a card is required, and you're charged only if you keep Tyasi after 14 days.S3 See everything Tyasi does or compare the plans.
A two-minute routine for every offer
- Open the offer and note when it expires: 24 hours after it arrives, or sooner if the listing ends.S1
- Compare it with your floor. If the listing is promoted, include the ad fee.S1S6
- At or above your target: accept. Between floor and target: accept, or counter if there's room under your Buy It Now price. Below your floor: counter somewhere between the floor and your Buy It Now price, or decline.S1S4
- When your costs change, update your floor and your auto-accept and minimum offer amounts with them.S1S4
eBay is a trademark of eBay Inc. Tyasi is an independent product, not affiliated with or endorsed by eBay.